Thursday, October 15, 2020

How Tarot Can You Go edition

There’s something about hitting the teens that’s scary.

As in days left until the election, I mean.

Not adolescence.

Or literally assaulting teenagers. Please don’t do that.

But we’re a whole 19 days out now, so there’s no time to waste.

The High Priestess: The fact that the election is less than three weeks away means it’s high time I unveil my state legislative chamber flip ratings.

Mostly I’m just going to be talking about the ones I’ve previously discussed as flippable for Dems, but I’m going to be sprinkling in bits about a few chambers that aren’t on this list, too.

Democrats are mostly agreed on which chambers are the highest priorities for the party this year (though reasonable minds can and do differ around the edges).

Factors considered in creating this target list include:

  • How many seats do Democrats need to flip to win a majority in the chamber?
  • Do past election results, political trends, or other factors indicate that Democrats can flip that many seats in a single election?
  • Was Democratic recruitment strong?
  • Do legislators in that state impact redistricting (some states, like California, task independent commissions with drawing legislative and congressional maps)?

Topmost among those targets are (in alphabetical order, nothing to read into here):

  • Arizona House (Dems need to flip two for a majority)
  • Arizona Senate (Dems need to flip three)
  • Michigan House (Dems need to flip four)
  • Minnesota Senate (flip two)
  • North Carolina House (flip six)
  • North Carolina Senate (flip five)
  • Pennsylvania House (flip nine)
  • Texas House (flip nine)
    • In Arizona, flipping either chamber would break the Republican trifecta. While legislative and congressional maps there are drawn by an independent redistricting commission, Republicans have spent the entire decade trying to undermine and dismantle the body; as long as the GOP has complete control of the state, fair redistricting is in real danger.
    • In Michigan, flipping the House would help stymie ongoing GOP efforts to dismantle or defang the independent redistricting commission the party’s been attacking since voters approved it in 2018.
    • In Minnesota, flipping the state Senate would give Democrats a governing trifecta (governorship, House, Senate) and complete control of the redistricting process.
    • Flipping at least one chamber in North Carolina is essential to preventing another GOP gerrymander of the state. The Democratic governor is generally favored to win reelection here, but it doesn’t matter—the legislature has complete control of legislative and congressional redistricting.
    • While Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf is positioned to veto egregious partisan gerrymanders sent to him by the legislature, flipping a chamber in Pennsylvania would give him a redistricting partner, so to speak, which would send him a fair map to approve, levy against the GOP in negotiations, or be considered by the Democratic-majority state Supreme Court in litigation.
    • Flipping the Texas House would break the GOP trifecta in the state and give Democrats a say in the redistricting process for the first time since the infamous DeLay-mander of 2003.

Helpfully, no Dem-held chambers are really in danger of flipping.

  • … unless you count the Alaska House, which is counted among Democratic-majority chambers but was actually a cobbled-together coalition of Dems, independents, and moderate Republicans.

And I say “was” for a reason.

  • This coalition recently disintegrated after two of its six GOP members lost their primaries in August and a third died in a plane crash.
  • The remaining three Republicans say they support GOP control of the chamber next year.
    • So Republicans may be able to technically chalk up a chamber flip in their column after Nov. 3—even if they fail to pick up a single seat in this chamber.

Bully for them. Let’s get back to the statehouses that matter this fall.

(A quick note: The ratings I use are Safe, Likely, Lean, Tossup. Don’t give me any of this “Tilt” nonsense; that just means you can’t make up your mind and/or don’t have the guts to commit.)

The Sun: Arizona House (31 R/29 D) and Senate (17 R/13 D): I’d say both of these chambers are tossups.

Here’s why:

  • Thanks to the deep-dive analysis of my Daily Kos Elections colleagues, we know that there’s very much a path to the majority in each chamber.

First, a quick primer on how legislative districts, like, work in Arizona, because its setup is a little different from most other states.

  • Arizona is divided into 30 legislative districts, and each one of these districts elects one senator and two state representatives every two years.
    • The districts are exactly the same for both chambers.
    • Each party can nominate up to two candidates for each House district, and voters can vote for their top two choices in the general election.
    • The two candidates with the most votes are elected.
  • Currently, Republicans have a 17-13 majority in the state Senate and a 31-29 majority in the House.
  • Neither chambers has a presiding tie-breaking entity (fun fact: Arizona doesn't have a lieutenant governor!), so a tie in either chamber would result in either
    • A power-sharing agreement, or
    • Defections from one party or the other.
      • Either way, it’s better to have that outright majority.
  • In 2016, Clinton carried 14 of the state’s 30 legislative districts as she lost the state to Donald Trump 49-45.
  • In 2018, Sinema carried those 14 districts and also won two districts that went for Trump.
    • These Sinema/Trump districts are LD-17 and LD-20.
      • LD-17 moved from 51-43 Trump to 50-47 Sinema.
      • LD-20 went from 49-45 Trump to 51-47 Sinema.

Let’s take a closer look at LD-17.

  • In 2018, Republican J.D. Mesnard won an open Senate race by a narrow 51-49 margin, so he’s a prime Democratic target for 2020.
    • He’s being challenged by Democrat AJ Kurdoglu, an immigrant and naturalized citizen who’s a small business owner and an ardent supporter of fully-funded public education and expanded access to quality health care.

And now for LD-20.

  • This district currently has an all-GOP delegation.
  • In the 2018 Senate race, Paul Boyer won an open seat 48-44.
    • He faces Democrat and Arizona native Doug Ervin this November.
  • In the 2018 House election, Republicans Anthony Kern and Shawnna Bolick took first and second place with 26 percent of the vote each, while a pair of Democrats were close behind with 24 percent apiece.
    • Teacher and community leader Judy Schwiebert is the only Democrat on the ballot in the district this year.

But possibly the most tantalizing prospect for Arizona Democrats this year is LD-28.

  • You see, this district went for both Clinton (50-45) and Sinema (55-43), but it still has a Republican in its legislative delegation.
    • GOP state Sen. Kate McGee barely managed to win re-election in 2018 by a margin of just 265 votes.
    • This fall, she’s in a rematch with Democrat Christine Marsh, a longtime educator (Arizona’s 2016 teacher of the year).

Both Trump and McSally won LD-06 (by 52-42 and 49-47, respectively), but this one is definitely on Dems’ target list.

So, the paths to Democratic majorities in the Arizona House and Senate are fairly narrow and certainly challenging, but they very much exist.

But these races don’t exist in a vacuum.

Downballot Democrats are going to be helped by high-performing members of their party in other races, too.

  • Mark Kelly seems all but certain to oust U.S. Senator Martha McSally.
    • Polling consistently has the Democrat with a strong lead in the race, and McSally’s, Trump’s, and GOP Gov. Doug Ducey’s unfavorables are all fairly high, indicating a general level of dissatisfaction with Republican governance in the state that is likely to aid the party currently out of power.

The Devil: Michigan House (58 R/52 D): Shouldn’t be a tossup (should Lean D) but is.

Not-so-fun-fact! Republicans have won a majority in the 110-seat Michigan House of Representatives since the last round of redistricting in 2011 despite Democrats winning more votes in three of the last four elections!

Yeah, that’s a solid GOP gerrymander for ya.

But despite the GOP’s incredibly skewed map, Democrats do have a path to a majority in the Wolverine State.

  • In 2018, Democrat Gretchen Whitmer defeated Republican Bill Schuette 53-44 to become governor and carried 56 of the 110 House seats—exactly the number that her party needs to take a majority.
    • Helpfully, no Democrats represent districts won by Schuette, which means that Republicans are playing defense in four seats Whitmer won.
      • That said, Trump won three of these four seats in 2016, so a sweep is a tall order for sure.

Let’s take a peek at those four districts.

A little more of a reach are HDs 38 and 39, both won by Trump in 2016 and by Whitmer in 2018.

  • HD-38 went for Trump 49-46 before supporting Whitmer 52-46.
  • HD-39 backed Trump 50-46, but Whitmer won it 53-45.
    • Republican incumbent Ryan Berman was elected to his first term in 2018 54-42, but that election took place under … unfortunate circumstances:
    • This time around, Berman faces Julia Pulver, a nurse who counts healthcare as her highest policy priority—a sure selling point as the pandemic continues to rage.
  • And finally there’s HD-45, which supported Whitmer just 49.2-48.8—a margin of 181 votes.
    • In 2016, Trump took the seat 51-44.
      • Republican incumbent Michael Webber won 55-45 in 2018, but he’s termed-out this year, depriving Republicans of the benefit of incumbency, at least.
    • Republican Mark Tisdel is running to succeed him.
      • He “supports most Trump policies” but “wishes the president would quit tweeting.”
    • Democrat Barb Anness is a small business owner and a local education board trustee whose years of education advocacy will strongly inform her priorities in the Michigan House.

So while these targets are super viable, flipping the Michigan House on Nov. 3 will require a lot to go right for Democrats.

  • Specifically, not only do they have to run the table in these four districts, but they also may have some defense to play.
    • Remember, 10 seats Democrats currently hold voted for Trump in 2016 (though they all went for Whitmer two years later).
  • But Democrats do have a perfectly viable long-shot target in HD-79, where young rising star Chokwe Pitchford is taking on incumbent Pauline Wendzel in a district Whitmer lost just 47-50.

The Star: Minnesota Senate (35 R/32 D): Likely D (hell yeah).

Womp womp

But!

  • In the special U.S. Senate election in 2018, Democrat Tina Smith carried 39 out of 67 districts.
  • Democrat Tim Walz carried those same 39 seats, plus two more.
  • Sen. Amy Klobuchar annihilated her GOP opponent and carried a ridiculous 52 of the 67 Senate seats, but a closer look reveals the most viable targets.
    • Eight of them, specifically, found among the eight Smith/Waltz districts currently represented by Republicans.
  • It’s worth noting, though, that only two of those seats supported Clinton in 2016 (SDs 44 and 56).
    • … which, well, is fine, since Democrats only have to flip two for that sweet Senate majority and hot trifecta action.
  • So, in addition to SDs 44 and 56, keep an eye on SDs 11, 14, 25, 26, 28, 34, 38, and 39.

Judgement: North Carolina House (65 R/55 D) and Senate (29 R/21 D): Lean R and Likely R, respectively.

By the by, the North Carolina House call is the toughest one of this bunch. I’m so close to rating it Tossup, but the maps are … ugh.

The bottom line is that Democrats acquiesced to GOP-drawn maps that do give Democrats the chance to win more seats this fall, but it’s still going to be challenging for the party to take a majority in either chamber.

… which, frankly, was always going to be the case to some extent.

Let’s take a look at the details.

  • Under the maps in effect this year, Trump took 72 House seats (out of 120) and 28 Senate districts (out of 50).
    • Translation: Even though Trump won just 51% of the vote in 2016, he’d still have won 59% of all seats in the legislature on these district lines.
  • So based on presidential performance in these districts, the current maps make it difficult for Democrats to shake the GOP’s grip on power.
  • But that’s not the whole story!
    • Again, these elections don’t take place in a vacuum.
    • Not only does North Carolina have Joe Biden with a slight edge over Trump on the presidential level, but there are two other high-profile statewide contests here this year.
    • Specifically, U.S. Senate and governor.
    • And Democrats not only have solid leads in both of those contests, but, for an incumbent governor running for reelection, Roy Cooper has ridiculously strong favorable/unfavorable numbers: 52%-44%, specifically.
    • This apparent faith in Democrats’ ability to govern the state will only benefit Democrats running to help him out in Raleigh next year.

Is flipping either chamber of the North Carolina legislature going to be easy?

Nope.

But it’s both absolutely doable and incredibly important.

Fun fact! In 2022, the Tar Heel State will have new legislative maps for the fourth cycle in a row.

The Tower: Pennsylvania House (110 R/ 93 D): Lean R.

With nine seats needed to flip the chamber to a Democratic majority, it’s certainly one of the heavier lifts on this list.

But, again, my colleagues dug into the numbers—specifically the 2018 gubernatorial and U.S. Senate results—and lo! They discovered a fairly heartening Democratic path to the majority.

  • Like most legislatures’ lower chambers, all members of the (203-seat!) Pennsylvania House are up for reelection every two years, so every seat is up this fall.
    • Republicans hold a 110-93 majority (there are a couple of vacancies, but we slot those in the column of the party that last held the seat).
  • I’m sure you recall that Donald Trump won Pennsylvania in 2016, but not only did he carry the state; he also took 119 of those 203 state House districts (Clinton carried 83).

Bummer, right?

Sure, but things change.

And in the Keystone State, change they did.

  • When Democratic U.S. Sen. Bob Casey won reelection over Republican Lou Barletta in 2018, he carried those 83 Clinton districts, plus 36 more. (...that’s 119.)
  • Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf did even better in his reelect that year, winning those 119 districts + 13 more (= 132).

So! The math looks good. Democrats just have to win a bunch of those Casey districts, right? And maybe some Wolf districts, just for fun?

Alas, it’s never that simple.

  • First thing to consider is that, of the Democrats currently in the chamber, there’s some defense to play.
    • Two Democrats are in seats won by Trump/Barletta/Wagner.
    • Three represent seats won by Trump/Barletta/Wolf.
    • Ten Dems serve in Trump/Casey/Wolf seats.
      • But, based on trends, it’s fair to not fret too much about those ten Democrats.
  • So, let’s assume anywhere from two to five Democrats are playing pretty serious defense this fall.

Not great, but it’s a better place to be than the Pennsylvania House GOP right now.

  • Here’s why:
    • Six Republicans occupy seats won by Clinton AND Casey AND Wolf.
      • Good targets! But even if Dems keep all their current seats, not enough.
    • However, another 25 Republicans represent seats that went for Trump in 2016 but shifted to Casey and Wolf in 2018.
      • So, even with Democrats playing some defense, there’s a fairly broad map to flipping the nine seats they need to win a Pennsylvania House majority.

But nine seats is a lot to flip in any cycle. Keystone Dems definitely have their work cut out for them.

However!

If the map were any more friendly, this would 100% be a Tossup. So close.

And last but most certainly anything but least,

Wheel of Fortune: Texas House (83 R/67 D): Tossup.

Yeah, you read that right.

  • That “flip nine” bit looks a little intimidating, but there’s good reason to be cautiously optimistic about this admittedly heavy lift of a state.
    • While the state Senate is safely in GOP hands (it’s a heavily gerrymandered 19 R/12 D chamber), the House is a viable target.
    • If Democrats can flip this chamber, they can block a sure-to-be severely gerrymandered Republican congressional map.
      • This would kick the process over to the courts, which is likely to result in districts that are more fair than anything drawn by the GOP (though the bar is extraordinarily low on that).
      • And fairer districts are likely to give Democrats and Latinos more opportunities to win congressional seats than any Republican map.
    • State legislative redistricting, however, would effectively remain in GOP hands, based on the process currently in place.

So, given the state of things (83 R/67 D), why am I kinda bullish on Democrats flipping those nine Texas House seats?

But it gets better!

So yeah, Texas.

Two years ago, it was hard to conceive including the state on any kind of single-election flip list.

But in November of 2018, Democrats picked up 12 seats, and voila! Here we are.

And speaking of where we are …

Congrats on slogging through all of that!

But tl;dr— 

  • Arizona House: Tossup.
  • Arizona Senate: Tossup.
  • Michigan House: Tossup.
  • Minnesota Senate: Likely D.
  • North Carolina House: Lean R.
  • North Carolina Senate: Likely R.
  • Pennsylvania House: Lean R.
  • Texas House: Tossup.

Just 19 more days before … well, before we won’t actually yet know which party will have majority control of some of these chambers.

Because so many state legislative races are decided each year by 100 votes or so (or fewer!), don’t expect to know where all of these states stand by the time you go to bed on election night.

It’ll take days to have full results. At least. Maybe even weeks.

That’s normal, and that’s okay.

But when all is said and done, I predict Democrats will flip at least four legislative chamber majorities.

If it’s an amazing night, Dems could flip seven.

  • They may only net three to six because of the Alaska shenanigans I explained up top, but a House majority in Texas means a lot more to the future of either party than a House majority in Alaska. (Sorry, Alaska. You're great and I love your deadly bears.)

But Alaska weirdness notwithstanding, Democrats aren’t actually really playing defense anywhere this year.

And there may be some sleeper flips—Iowa House, e.g. It’s a long shot, but it’s worth keeping an eye on.

Also … the Republican State Leadership Committee is making some spending decisions that could be defined as … questionable?

Like, for instance, the org’s spending on ads in a Georgia House race.

  • The RSLC is targeting the chamber’s Minority Leader, and it’s always fun to decapitate the opposition, but … this is really how Republicans are spending money?
    • Almost $700,000, they claim.
  • To flip a single seat in a Deep South chamber they hold 105-74?

Y’all I just don’t know

Well, that’s my spread (tarot joke!) for 2020 state legislative elections.

I’m a notorious pragmatist when it comes to these contests, and I hope my prediction of just four chamber flips is something we all laugh at me for in the weeks following the election when it turns out to be actually, like, 10.

It’s not going to be 10

  • Oh, and just because I’m not talking about Republican lawmakers in places like Pennsylvania and Wisconsin pulling shenanigans with electors and mail-in ballots to throw presidential election results into chaos doesn’t mean I’m not still super worried about it.
    • You can see me talk about how doggone worried I am about it on this week’s episode of The Brief, Daily Kos’ new politics show (my bit starts at 29:25), if you have time time to kill and need a laugh from looking at all the weird faces I make.

(The whole ep is really quite excellent—the amazing Elie Mystal is a tough act to follow for sure!)


Friday, September 25, 2020

All Falls Down edition

 

Happy autumn!

… except nothing is happy and it feels like it never will be again.

But wallowing in our anguish is a luxury we can’t afford, and besides, as one of my favorite philosophers is known for saying, “Pain don’t hurt.”

What does hurt, though, is knowing that nearly a decade of Democratic down-ballot neglect could assist Donald Trump’s schemes to remain in the White House at any cost.

As an erudite consumer of this missive, you’re likely aware of the dark political reality we face right now: Trump and those in his orbit are actively scheming and laying groundwork—rhetorical, legal, and otherwise—to cast doubt on the result of this presidential election if it doesn’t go his way.

The ways Trump might go about that are myriad. But one in particular could very much come into play in key swing states with GOP-controlled legislatures.

… which, thanks to gerrymandering, is all of those key swing states.

  • Florida? 23 R/17 D Senate, 73 R/47 D House.
  • Michigan? 22 R/16 D Senate, 58 R/51 D House (1 vacancy).
  • North Carolina? 29 R/21 D Senate, 65 R/55 D House.
  • Pennsylvania? 28 R/21 D Senate, 109 R/92 D House (2 vacancies).
  • Wisconsin? 19 R/14 D Senate, 63 R/36 D Assembly.

So, why might this matter?

An expansive Atlantic piece about the various ways this election could go extremely pear-shaped published just this week leaned on a Loyola University Chicago Law Journal article to game out a pretty plausible hypothetical in Pennsylvania.

Here’s how it could go down:

  • As you know, in every state but two, the winner of that state’s popular vote gets all of that state’s electoral votes.
    • In Maine and Nebraska, two electors are assigned based on the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote, but if the other candidate wins any of that state’s congressional districts, the remaining electors are allocated accordingly.
  • Every state’s electoral votes are cast by a pre-selected slate of electors determined by each party earlier in the year.

So, imagine it’s election night.

Polls are closing. Voters have been voting.

Lots of voters actually voted weeks ago by mailing in their ballots.

  • But in some states, election officials can’t begin counting those mail-in ballots until Election Day itself.
    • And counting those ballots takes a while! They have to be removed from envelopes, unfolded, signatures verified, etc. before they’re ever fed into a counting machine or undergo whatever tabulation method that state employs.
  • In Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, the counting of mail-in ballots can’t begin until Election Day.
    • Election officials get a bit of a head start in Florida and North Carolina.

In Pennsylvania, more than 2 million voters have already requested the state mail them absentee ballots.

  • Of that number, 70% are Democrats.
    • Which means fewer Democrats plan to cast their votes in person on Election Day relative to the number of Republicans planning to do so.

So, right, it’s election night.

Pennsylvania’s in-person votes get tallied as the laborious endeavor of counting those mail-in ballots also gets under way.

By the next morning, all of the in-person votes will have been counted.

But it’s likely that the counting of the mail-in ballots will still be going on.

  • Pennsylvania is a closely divided state in terms of partisan propensity.
    • Biden is generally favored to win here, but not by the ridiculous margin probably required to give him an obviously insurmountable lead by the time most Americans go to bed on election night.

Ballot counting continues into Nov. 4, but Trump is already calling for a halt, baselessly screaming about fraud and illegal voting and Martians invading or something.

Seriously, who knows? All we know is that he’ll claim anything to serve his cause.

  • In a non-Trump reality, vote tallying would continue, election officials would certify the results, that candidate’s electors would cast their ballots on Dec. 14, and life would go on.

But this hypothetical is taking place in the Trump era.

And Trump and his ilk are already telling us what they’re going to do.

  • So, say Biden’s small Nov. 3 vote deficit goes away or his small lead increases as more and more mail-in ballots are counted into Nov. 4 (and likely beyond).
    • Election officials certify the results, and Pennsylvania’s Democratic governor sends a “certificate of ascertainment” to the National Archives and the president of the. U.S. Senate, thus notifying the federal government of which candidate’s electors have been officially appointed.

But election results in Pennsylvania won’t be certified until Nov. 11.

Which gives Republicans a full week to stir shit.

And, as we know all too well these days, a lot can happen in a week.

  • During this week, Trump and his allies would be clamoring for vote-counting to stop and screaming that any votes counted after Nov. 3 (never mind that they were received days or weeks earlier) are somehow fraudulent.
  • The Republicans who control the state legislature take this cue and claim that the vote tally can’t be trusted because it keeps (logically!) shifting in Biden’s favor as more of those overwhelmingly Democratic mail-in ballots get counted.
  • So suddenly those Republican lawmakers decide that Article II of the U.S. Constitution allows them to ex post facto allocate electors as they see fit, rather than the voters of Pennsylvania.
    • They’ll yell about how the vote tally is “suspect” or “questionable” or “fraudulent” or whatever suits them, and they’ll claim that Article II gives them the authority to supersede the actually very legitimate results and replace the duly appointed Democratic electors with electors of their own choosing.
      • Which would be Trump electors, naturally.
  • Legal theories and claims will be thrown about, but in our hypothetical, ultimately these Trump electors meet and send their own “certificate of ascertainment” to the National Archives and the president of the U.S. Senate.
    • … who just happens to be the vice president sharing a ballot with Trump.

So, when Congress convenes on Jan. 6, 2021, to officially count the electoral votes, they have two conflicting certificates of ascertainment from Pennsylvania.

  • Imagine this also happening in Michigan, where absentee ballot requests are already twice what they were in 2016.
    • Election results aren’t certified there until Nov. 23, giving the GOP even more time to pull shenanigans.
  • And let’s add Wisconsin, where mail-in ballot requests are more than six times what they were in 2016.

Scared yet?

A Trump campaign legal adviser has reportedly already affirmed that this GOP state legislator interference strategy is very much a part of the campaign’s playbook.

But what are Republicans in these states saying?

Ooooh I hope you weren’t expecting reassurance

Reporters have begun to ask other GOP leaders in other states about this Trump vote-invalidation scheme.

  • While a spokesperson fo the Wisconsin Elections Commission correctly responded to a reporter’s inquiry that existing law in the state doesn’t give lawmakers the ability to choose electors, I’d like to point out that state law doesn’t outright prohibit it, either.
    • GOP Assembly Speaker Robin Vos claims that “there’s no such effort” to invalidate actual election results in Wisconsin.
      • Republican Senate President Scott Fitzgerald didn’t respond to requests for comment.
    • But Vos already has a history of casting doubt on narrow statewide Democratic victories.
      • After Democrat Tony Evers narrowly defeated GOP Gov. Scott Walker in 2018, Vos suggested that Wisconsin’s two largest cities—Milwaukee and Madison—shouldn’t really count.

Because over 800,000 Wisconsinites’ votes shouldn’t count because they happen to live in cities, I guess?

  • But let’s extrapolate that attitude towards a hotly contested, close presidential election in the state.

And!

  • Yet another thing we can expect from Republicans this year is active voter intimidation and suppression efforts at urban polling locations.

How do we know this?

Because one of Trump’s top reelection advisers was caught on tape saying as much.

  • You see, way back in 1981, the RNC and the New Jersey GOP had off-duty policy stand at polling places in urban areas wearing armbands that read “National Ballot Security Task Force” as voters cast ballots in that year’s gubernatorial election. Some of these cops were visibly armed.
    • The DNC sued, alleging that this conduct was designed to intimidate Black voters.
    • Without admitting what they were actually up to, the RNC agreed to a consent decree restricting Republicans’ ability to engage in activities allegedly related to “ballot security.”
  • In 2018, a judge lifted that consent decree.
    • And a Trump official has promised that Republicans are going to “start playing offense” and have “a much more aggressive program” in light of these newly relaxed restrictions.

I mention this in the context of Wisconsin because that’s where this admission was recorded.

But it’s fair to expect to see the GOP executing overt voter intimidation activities in cities in every swing state.

But anyway, let's take a quick look at the other states the Trump campaign might try this “elector invalidation” scheme in.

  • In North Carolina, Republicans would need to convene a special session to pull off such an antic, and they lack the three-fifths majority the House and Senate required to do so (and obviously Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper isn't going to call one).
  • Florida’s Republican legislators (they controlled the legislature even back then) sort of pulled this Trump stunt back in back in 2000.
    • The GOP governor and GOP secretary of state had already submitted the state’s “certificate of ascertainment,” but Democrats were disputing the outcome.
    • Republican lawmakers were reportedly preparing to replace Democratic electors if the ensuing court battles didn’t go their way (but, obviously, SCOTUS ruled in the GOP’s favor in Bush v. Gore).
      • So we can fairly assume the current crop of Republican lawmakers won’t hesitate to do the same (and their GOP governor certainly won’t stand in their way).
  • In Michigan—that other state that won’t start counting mail-in ballots until Election Day itself—Republican legislative leaders haven’t yet gone on record saying they won’t seek to replace Democratic electors with their own party’s or that they won’t cast doubt on election results they don’t like.
    • Michigan Republicans are, however, fighting tooth and nail to not count ballots postmarked by Nov. 2 but received after Election Day.
      • So it’s not a stretch to imagine GOP lawmakers will seek to cast doubt on the legitimacy of those ballots.
      • And thus cast doubt on a narrow and/or growing Biden victory.
        • And the legislature here will still be in session, so Republicans are free to convene and pull all manner of elector shenanigans.

Is it pretty extreme to claim that Republican legislators are likely to help Trump steal the presidential election?

Sure. But it’s also entirely within the realm of possibility.

  • And Republicans in all of these states have spent the past decade doing whatever they deem necessary to hold on to power—everything from gerrymandering to passing voter suppression laws to stealing power from Democratic governors to busting the unions that used to be major parts of Democratic infrastructure in many of these states.

I’ve been watching these cats for ten years. Literally nothing they do would surprise me.

  • … including subverting the will of their own states’ voters to steal the presidency for a member of their own party.

They’ve neither feared nor faced real repercussions for their naked exercises of partisan power so far.

So why would they start worrying about it now?

Okay, that was a super bummer, so let me at least round this out with some positive news.

With everything else going on, it’s totally understandable if you didn’t notice that the nation's primary elections finally concluded last week.

Democracy hooray!

This means that my extremely excellent Daily Kos Elections colleagues have finally been able to complete the 2020 edition of the Daily Kos Elections State Legislative Open Seat Tracker! 

And the news is ... good!

  • Overall, Democrats are contesting more Republican-held seats at the legislative level than the reverse.
  • Also, fewer Democratic incumbents have opted to retire.

These are legitimate reasons for optimism about Democrats’ down-ballot prospects across the country!

  • This year, 5,876 seats are on the ballot across 86 legislative chambers in 44 states nationwide.
    • We've counted 361 Republican and 298 Democratic incumbents who are calling it quits this fall.
    • An additional 113 Republicans and 82 Democrats are term-limited and will not be on their states' respective ballots this November.
    • And 90 Republican and 60 Democratic incumbents were defeated in primary elections this year.

A detailed seat-by-seat look at each open seat and their underlying partisan lean (as measured by 2016 and 2012 presidential election results, where available) is listed on the second tab of the chart.

  • As part of this tracking, we've also kept track of the number of seats held by each party that are being left uncontested in the November elections.
    • 1,047 seats held by Democrats with no Republican opposition, or roughly 38% of Democratic seats on the ballot this year.
    • At the same time, 1,013 Republican-held seats, or 33% of the GOP's total, have no Democratic challengers.

Put another way, Democrats are fielding 2,035 candidates for seats held by Republicans, while the GOP has only put up 1,709 candidates for seats held by Democrats.

While every year is an important year for state legislative races, the impending round of redistricting makes 2020 especially urgent.

… but you knew that already